Shadow, the startup behind the catastrophic Iowa caucuses earlier this year, has quietly lost its majority funder, rebranded itself, and changed its CEO to help chart a new, more focused direction in 2020.
What was once called Shadow Inc. is now called BlueLink, a recent restructuring that was almost certainly necessary after Shadow became embroiled in controversy for creating the flawed and hastily built app that sowed confusion and significantly delayed the reporting of the results of Iowa’s Democratic caucuses. It’s part of an attempt by the company to move past a massive blunder that not only jeopardized Shadow the company, but also cast shadows over the Democratic Party’s tech and Silicon Valley donors’ abilities to bring their know-how to the party.
“If there’s ever a time for a rebrand,” then-CEO, Gerard Niemira, told Recode in May, “this is it.”
Niemira and the company’s majority investor, a constellation of progressive political groups called Acronym, became some of the most despised forces in Democratic politics after the app’s technical difficulties in February delayed results for a week and robbed the caucus winners of their momentum. Now, ahead of the general election — when the Democratic Party will need its digital efforts to prove error-free — the group is trying to move forward.
“Obviously when something like Iowa happens, it’s important to take stock,” Niemira said.
But the newly rebranded BlueLink will have to accomplish this without ACRONYM, which told Recode that it decided after Iowa in February to “wind down our involvement with Shadow” and that, as of May, it is in the process of divesting from the company.
Niemiera is now also out as CEO of BlueLink as part of a quiet leadership shakeup. Niemiera told Recode in May that he was bringing on more help with Irene Tollinger, a Silicon Valley designer and product executive, who Niemiera said would be BlueLink’s chief operating officer. But just a few months later, on BlueLink’s newly designed website, it is Tollinger listed as CEO — with Niemiera not listed anywhere on its “Team” page. Tollinger confirmed to Recode on Tuesday that Niemiera had stepped down and that she had taken the CEO role.
Niemiera said in May that Tollinger would oversee what the startup is hoping will be a return to its foundational work: integrating data for campaigns neatly into one place, rather than developing caucus apps beyond its expertise. Niemira said then that he was talking to Tollinger — who calls herself in her Twitter bio an “untangler of thorny problems” — before the Iowa screw-up, but she is expected to oversee its main business line — the data work called LightRail — going forward.
The other pillar of the company’s work, software that allows campaigns to text voters and volunteers, won’t be a priority after the November elections because of the crowd of other progressive vendors that have begun offering similar services, Niemira said. He also vowed to kill one-off projects like the Iowa app.
“My cardinal sin with the Iowa stuff was distracting the team,” he said.
But even with a more focused company, it’s not clear that the startup that brought you the Iowa caucuses will be able to escape its history. Acronym as of May remained its majority investor, Niemira said, but with Acronym eventually cutting ties, BlueLink will have to find other donors going forward. And while lines like “When a light is shining, Shadows are a constant companion,” were scrubbed from its old website, Niemira seemed well aware that partners will easily be able to figure out that the company remains essentially the same product in a new wrapper.
It’s a cover, he acknowledged with a knowing laugh, that is “pretty thin.” But that’s better than continuing to run one of the most hated brands in Democratic politics.
“It wasn’t fun for me personally, I can tell you that. It remains not fun,” Niemira said of what happened in Iowa. “But you got to get up and do the work every day, whether it’s coronavirus, bad press, or anything else that comes your way.”
Update, July 14: This article has been updated with the news of BlueLink’s CEO change.
Support Vox’s explanatory journalism
Every day at Vox, we aim to answer your most important questions and provide you, and our audience around the world, with information that has the power to save lives. Our mission has never been more vital than it is in this moment: to empower you through understanding. Vox’s work is reaching more people than ever, but our distinctive brand of explanatory journalism takes resources — particularly during a pandemic and an economic downturn. Your financial contribution will not constitute a donation, but it will enable our staff to continue to offer free articles, videos, and podcasts at the quality and volume that this moment requires. Please consider making a contribution to Vox today.